BuyAffordabilitySellRentMarketSold
HomeSearchSavedMarket
BuyAffordabilitySellRentMarketSold
Home · Buy · Tay · 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0+ 24 photos
For Sale · Detached

58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0

Tay · Port McNicoll
◷56 days on market
BungalowEast exposure
▶ Virtual Tour
3
Beds
2
Baths
0
Parking
1100-1500
Sq ft
—
Built
The honest picture
List price
$899,900
★ Renavu Estimate
$868,000
★★★★★★★★★★Lower confidence
Comparable sales vary too widely to call a direction
Renavu Estimate is our data-driven opinion of value, blended from 6 recent comparable sales — not an appraisal. The area price benchmark for this neighbourhood is still being prepared.

About this home

A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by. The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Muskoka room for extra sleeping quarters or peaceful retreat. This cottage can sleep up to 10 people comfortably. The hot tub extends your days outdoors into the evenings with sounds of laughter and joy from the kids. Inside turn on Netflix and watch movies on the 75 big screen. High speed internet when working remotely is top notch. This is more than a cottage, its a lifestyle!

Property details

Listed on
July 21, 2026
Days on market
56 days
Property tax
$3,669.47 (2025)
Lot
77.1 × 220 Feet
Style
Bungalow
Heating
Baseboard
MLS®
S13588020

Full details

Parking
GarageNone

Room dimensions

RoomLevelDimensionsFeatures
Bedroom 3Main3.15 × 4.32—
BedroomMain4.47 × 4.06—
Bedroom 2Main3.15 × 2.94—
KitchenMain5.2 × 9.34—
Living RoomMain5.2 × 5.03—
BathroomMain2.1 × 1.143 Pc Ensuite
BathroomMain3.15 × 1.244 Pc Bath
SunroomMain3.33 × 2.77—

Property & sold history

Listing history
Date StartDate EndPriceStatusListing ID
July 21, 2026—$899,900For SaleS13588020
🔒

Earlier listings and sold prices for this address are protected under TRREB rules — a free account unlocks them.

Sign in free to unlock the history

Comparables

Gathering recent comparable sales nearby…

Run the numbers

True cost to close
What you actually need in cash — land transfer tax, closing costs, and your down payment.
Purchase price
$
Down payment · 20.0%
$
Down:or type any amount above
This price requires at least 7.2% down (5% on the first $500K, 10% above).
Legal fees
$
Title insurance
$
Home inspection
$
Ontario land transfer tax$14,473
Legal · title · inspection$2,800
Closing costs$17,273
Down payment$179,980
Total cash to close$197,253
Estimates only, not legal or tax advice. Ontario LTT rates 2025; City of Toronto MLTT applies inside Toronto (incl. Scarborough, North York, Etobicoke, York, East York). Durham and Markham buyers pay no municipal LTT.
$899,900
MLS® S13588020 · Listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
▶ Virtual Tour
Homes in Port McNicoll are selling at 98% of asking.

That's from 20 recent sales nearby. Want to know what it means for yours?

Get my Port McNicoll valuation
Call The Renavu Team
Shan Perinpanathan
Shan Perinpanathan
Real Estate Broker, ABR, SRS
416.655.4040
Pam Thiyagarajah
Pam Thiyagarajah
Sales Representative
416.436.0546
Ragu Rajaguru
Ragu Rajaguru
Real Estate Broker
416.712.2006

Price and status changes on this home only. No newsletter, and no call unless you ask for one. Unsubscribe from any email. The Renavu Team, Royal LePage Ignite Realty, Brokerage.

One team. No spam. We reach out once — when you ask.

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.. Presented by Royal LePage Ignite Realty, Brokerage. Data provided by TRREB — deemed reliable but not guaranteed; for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. Listing information last updated July 21, 2026.

$899,900

Real estate, navigated. Transparent, data-first representation across the Greater Toronto Area.

Royal LePage Ignite Realty, Brokerage

Independently owned and operated.

Explore

BuySellRentMarket statsNew homes

Company

The teamContact usJoin the teamBlogTrusted partnersUtilities Directory

Areas we serve

Durham
Ajax · Brock · Clarington · Oshawa · Pickering · Scugog · Uxbridge · Whitby
York
Aurora · East Gwillimbury · Georgina · King · Markham · Newmarket · Richmond Hill · Vaughan · Whitchurch-Stouffville
Toronto
Toronto · Scarborough (E10) · Scarborough (E11)
Peel
Mississauga · Brampton · Caledon
Halton
Oakville · Burlington · Halton Hills · Milton

© 2026 The Renavu Team · Royal LePage Ignite Realty, Brokerage · Privacy · Terms · · We don't sell your data.

The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose.

Listing data is provided by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) through PropTx and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by PropTx. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. IDX information is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use.

Similar homes for sale

Comparable homes on the market near Tay · Port McNicoll — same kind of property, similar size and price.

31 Earldom Boulevard, Tay, ON L0K 1R0For sale: $769,000
3 bed2 bath9 parking (+9)
1100–1500 sq ft3 km
Detached
31 Earldom Boulevard, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
363 Wardell Street, Tay, ON L0K 1R0For sale: $634,999
3 + 2 bed2 bath9 parking (+9)
1100–1500 sq ft2.8 km
Detached
363 Wardell Street, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
461 Barnes Avenue, Tay, ON L0K 1R0For sale: $549,990
3 + 2 bed2 bath7 parking (+7)
1100–1500 sq ft3 km
Detached
461 Barnes Avenue, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
575 Simcoe Avenue, Tay, ON L0K 1R0For sale: $499,900
3 + 1 bed2 bath3 parking (+3)
1100–1500 sq ft3.4 km
Detached
575 Simcoe Avenue, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, ON L0K 1R0For sale: $699,000
3 bed3 bath (+1)4 parking (+4)
1100–1500 sq ft3.1 km
Detached
753 Fifth Avenue, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
9 SWAN Lane 44, Tay, ON L0K 1R0For sale: $1,094,405
2 bed (-1)1 bath (-1)2 parking (+2)
1100–1500 sq ft2.2 km
Detached
9 SWAN Lane 44, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
See everything for sale nearby

Comparables

Homes near 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
Sold🔒 Sold:
bed bath parking
sq ft km
Detached
Address shown after sign-in
See what it sold for →
Sold🔒 Sold:
bed bath parking
sq ft km
Detached
Address shown after sign-in
See what it sold for →
Sold🔒 Sold:
bed bath parking
sq ft km
Detached
Address shown after sign-in
See what it sold for →
Sold🔒 Sold:
bed bath parking
sq ft km
Detached
Address shown after sign-in
See what it sold for →
Sold🔒 Sold:
bed bath parking
sq ft km
Detached
Address shown after sign-in
See what it sold for →
Sold🔒 Sold:
bed bath parking
sq ft km
Detached
Address shown after sign-in
See what it sold for →
🔒

6 sold homes nearby

You're looking at real recent sales near here. Sign in free to reveal the sold prices, addresses and photos — sold data is protected under TRREB rules.

Sign in free to unlock